銆婂寳浠茶祫璁�绗簩鍗佷簩鏈�/title> <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=gb2312"> <link href="images/font.css" rel="stylesheet" type="text/css"> <meta name="description" content="鍖椾含浠茶濮斿憳浼氭槸浠ヤ徊瑁佺殑鏂瑰紡锛岀嫭绔嬨�鍏銆侀珮鏁堝湴瑙ｅ喅骞崇瓑涓讳綋鐨勫叕姘戙�娉曚汉鍜屽叾浠栫粍缁囦箣闂村彂鐢熺殑鍚堝悓绾犵悍鍜屽叾浠栬储浜ф潈鐩婄籂绾风殑甯歌浠茶鏈烘瀯銆傚寳浠蹭富浠荤敱钁楀悕娉曞瀹舵睙骞虫暀鎺堟媴浠伙紝鍓富浠诲強濮斿憳鐢辨硶寰嬨�璐告槗銆侀噾铻嶇瓑棰嗗煙涓叿澶囪祫娣辩粡鍘嗕笖寰烽珮鏈涢噸鐨勪笓瀹跺拰瀛﹁�缁勬垚銆傚姙鍏鏄寳浠茬殑甯歌鍔炰簨鏈烘瀯锛岃礋璐ｆ墽琛屽鍛樹細鍐宠鍜屽鐞嗘棩甯镐簨鍔°�" > <meta name="keywords" content="浠茶,浠茶濮斿憳浼�鍖椾含浠茶濮斿憳浼�鍖椾徊"> <style type="text/css">  </style> </head> <body bgcolor="#ffffff" leftmargin="0" topmargin="0"> <table width="100%" border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"> <tr> <td> </td> <td width="811"align="center"><table width="811" border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"> <tr> <td width="670"><a href="http://www.bjac.org.cn" target="_blank"><img name="zhengwen_r1_c2" src="images/zhengwen_r1_c2.jpg" width="670" height="126" border="0" alt="鍓嶅線鍖椾徊涓枃缃戠珯"></a></td> <td width="123" valign="bottom"><p> </p> <p><a href="../english/20110710/comment.htm"><img src="images/english.jpg" width="75" height="19" border="0"></a></p> <p><img src="images/shisi.jpg" width="154" height="19"></p></td> </tr> </table> <a href="../080710/mulu.htm"></a></td> <td> </td> </tr> <tr> <td background="images/zhengwen_r4_c1.jpg" height=7 colspan="3"></td> </tr> <tr> <td > </td> <td align="center"><table width="811" border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"> <tr> <td width="23%"> </td> <td width="77%"> </td> </tr> <tr> <td valign="top"><table width="181" height="352" border="0" align="center" cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0"> <tr> <td valign="top" background="images/left_menu_bg.jpg" ><table width="176" border="0" cellspacing="4" cellpadding="2"> <tr> <td width="48"> </td> <td width="108"> </td> </tr> <tr> <td> </td> <td> </td> </tr> <tr> <td> </td> <td> </td> </tr> <tr> <td><div align="right"><img src="images/dianhua.jpg" width="18" height="15"></div></td> <td height="30"><a href="yaowen.htm" class="mulu">鍖椾徊瑕侀椈</a></td> </tr> <tr> <td><div align="right"><img src="images/dianhua.jpg" width="18" height="15"></div></td> <td height="30"><a href="dongtai.htm" class="mulu">涓氬唴鍔ㄦ�</a></td> </tr> <tr> <td><div align="right"><img src="images/dianhua.jpg" width="18" height="15"></div></td> <td height="30"><a href="pinglun.htm" class="mulu">浠茶璇勮</a></td> </tr> <tr> <td><div align="right"><img src="images/dianhua.jpg" width="18" height="15"></div></td> <td height="30"><a href="guanzhu.htm" class="mulu">鐗瑰埆鍏虫敞</a></td> </tr> <tr> <td><div align="right"><img src="images/dianhua.jpg" width="18" height="15"></div></td> <td height="30"><a href="sudi.htm" class="mulu">鏂版硶閫熼�</a></td> </tr> <tr> <td> </td> <td><a href="index.htm"><img src="images/fanhui.jpg" width="66" height="26" border="0"></a></td> </tr> </table></td> </tr> </table></td> <td valign="top"><table width="100%" border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"> <tr> <td width="2%"> </td> <td width="98%"><table width="100%" border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="2"> <tr> <td width="60%"><img name="zhengwen_r6_c5" src="images/menu/pinglun.jpg" width="192" height="45" border="0" alt=""></td> <td width="40%"><div align="right"><a href="zhengao.htm"><img src="images/zhengao.jpg" width="192" height="45" border="0"></a></div></td> </tr> </table></td> </tr> <tr> <td> </td> <td> </td> </tr> <tr> <td> </td> <td> <div align="center"><span class="toptitle"><strong>娑夊浠茶鍗忚鏁堝姏璁ゅ畾鐨勮鍒ゆ柟娉�/strong></span><br> 鈥斺�浠モ�浠茶鍦板湪棣欐腐閫傜敤鑻卞浗娉曗�涓轰緥瀹嬭繛鏂�sup>*</sup></div> <p><strong> 鎽樿</strong>锛氣�浠茶鍦板湪棣欐腐閫傜敤鑻卞浗娉曗�杩欐牱鐨勭畝鐭徊瑁佹潯娆撅紝瀹炶返涓緝涓哄父瑙侊紝浣嗗浣曡瀹氬叾鏁堝姏锛屽垯浣滄硶涓嶄竴銆備粠瑁佸垽鏂规硶鐨勮搴﹁В鍓栧疄闄呮渚嬶紝鏈夊姪浜庢槑鏅拌绫绘浠跺簲璇ラ噰鐢ㄧ殑瑁佸垽鏂规硶锛屼互淇濇寔鍒ゅ喅鐨勪竴鑷存�锛氬湪浜嬪疄璁ゅ畾涓婏紝涓昏鏄繍鐢ㄥ悎鍚岃В閲婄殑鏂规硶鐣屽畾浠茶鍗忚鐨勫惈涔夛紝鏄庣‘褰撲簨浜烘槸鍚︽湁鐪熷疄鐨勪徊瑁佹剰鍥撅紱鍦ㄦ硶寰嬮�鐢ㄤ笂锛岄�甯告硶瀹橀潰涓村弻閲嶆壘娉曪紝鍗冲彂鐜板彲閫傜敤鐨勫啿绐佽鑼冨強閫氳繃鍐茬獊瑙勮寖纭畾浠茶鍗忚鐨勫噯鎹硶銆傚湪纭畾鍑嗘嵁娉曟椂锛屽挨闇�敞鎰忓鍥芥硶鐨勬煡鏄庨棶棰樸� </p> <p><strong> 鍏抽敭璇�/strong>锛氫徊瑁佸崗璁�娑夊 浠茶鍑嗘嵁娉�瑁佸垽鏂规硶 <br> 锛堟帴涓婃枃锛�</p> <p><strong>浜屻�瑙ｆ瀽锛氭褰撳寲杩囩▼鐨勬効鏅�/strong><strong> </strong></p> <p> 娑夊浠茶鍗忚鐨勬晥鍔涜瀹氾紝骞朵笉闇�涓�涓嶅悓浜庡叾瀹冩秹澶栨皯鍟嗕簨妗堜欢鐨勭壒娈婅鍒ゆ柟娉曘�浣嗛渶瑕佽鏄庣殑鏄紝娉曞畼鍜屼徊瑁佸憳鍦ㄩ�鐢ㄨ鍒ゆ柟娉曚笂鏈夐噸澶у尯鍒紝鍚庤�鐨勭壒娈婃�瀹滃彟鏂囪杩帮紝鏈枃浠呬粠娉曞畼鐨勮瑙掑嚭鍙戙�鍙傜収娑夊姘戝晢浜嬫浠剁殑鏍囧噯娴佺▼锛�sup>1</sup> 娑夊浠茶鍗忚鏁堝姏璁ゅ畾鐨勫徃娉曡繃绋嬪涓嬶細 <br> 娑夊浠茶鍗忚鏁堝姏浜夎鈥斺啋绠¤緰鏉冣�鈫掍簨瀹炶瀹氣�鈫掓硶寰嬮�鐢ㄢ�鈫掕鍒�<br> 缁撹鐨勫舰鎴愪篃鏄熀浜庡徃娉曢�杈戜笁娈佃锛�<br> T鈫扲锛圧閫傜敤浜嶵鎵�寚涔嬩换浣曟浠讹紝澶у墠鎻愶紝鍗虫秹澶栦徊瑁佸崗璁簲閫傜敤鐨勬硶寰嬶級 <br> S锛漈锛圫鏄疶鎵�寚涔嬫浠朵箣涓�紝灏忓墠鎻愶紝鍗虫秹澶栦徊瑁佸崗璁殑瀛樺湪鍙婄湡瀹炲惈涔夛級 <br> 鈥斺�鈥斺� <br> S锛漅锛圧閫傜敤浜嶴锛屽嵆缁撹锛�</p> <p> 鍏朵腑锛屾硶寰嬮�鐢ㄥ氨鏄壘娉曪紙鍙戠幇娉曞緥锛夈�閲婃硶锛堝帢娓呮硶寰嬬殑鍚箟锛変笌鐢ㄦ硶锛涗笁娈佃鍏紡鍗虫槸灏嗗凡缁忓彂鐜板苟纭畾鍚箟鐨勬硶寰嬭鑼冧笌缁忚瀹氱殑浜嬪疄寤虹珛娑垫憚鍏崇郴锛屼互瑙勮寖鏉ヨ瘎浠蜂簨瀹烇紝骞跺緱鍑烘槸鍚︿骇鐢熻娉曞緥瑙勮寖鎵�寚鍚庢灉鐨勭粨璁恒�娑夊浠茶鍗忚鏁堝姏璁ゅ畾涓紝澶氬崐瀛樺湪鍙岄噸娉曞緥鍙戠幇锛屽嵆棣栧厛鏄彂鐜板啿绐佽鑼冿紝鍏舵鍩轰簬鍐茬獊瑙勮寖纭畾鍑嗘嵁娉曘�鑰岄�甯哥殑鍐呭浗妗堜欢涓紝鎵炬硶灏辨槸鎸囩‘瀹氬彲浠ョ敤浣滆鍒や緷鎹殑瀹炰綋娉曘�闇�璇存槑鐨勬槸锛屼互涓婃弿杩版棤鎰忓泭鎷秹澶栦徊瑁佸崗璁晥鍔涜瀹氱殑鎵�湁瑁佸垽鏂规硶锛岃�鍙槸鎻愪緵涓�釜鍩烘湰鐨勫垎鏋愭鏋躲� </p> <p> 锛堜竴锛変竴瀹¤瀹氳瘎鏋�</p> <p> 鏈褰撲簨浜哄鑸绉熻埞鍚堝悓涓徊瑁佹潯娆剧殑瀛樺湪鍙婂叾琛ㄨ堪骞舵棤寮傝锛屽彧鏄璇ユ潯娆剧殑娉曞緥璇勪环鎰忚鐩稿乏锛氬師鍛婅涓轰徊瑁佹潯娆炬棤鏁堬紝鏁呭悜娉曢櫌灏卞疄浣撲簤璁彁璧疯瘔璁硷紱琚憡璁や负浠茶鏉℃鏈夋晥锛屾硶闄㈠妗堜欢鏃犵杈栨潈锛屾牴鎹垜鍥界浉鍏虫硶寰嬭瀹氾紝鏈搴旂敱棣欐腐鍞竴鐨勪徊瑁佹満鏋勯娓浗闄呬徊瑁佷腑蹇冭繘琛屼徊瑁併�鍙互璇达紝鏈鐨勬鎯呰緝涓虹畝鍗曪紝浜夎鐐逛篃寰堝崟涓��姝ゆ椂锛屾硶瀹樿鍋氱殑鏄袱浠朵簨锛氳瀹氫簨瀹炲拰閫傜敤娉曞緥銆備篃灏辨槸璇达紝涓轰簡寰楀嚭瑁佸垽缁撹锛屽厛瑕佺‘瀹氬皬鍓嶆彁锛屽啀纭畾澶у墠鎻愶紝鍙湁鍓嶆彁姝ｇ‘锛岀粨璁烘墠鍙兘姝ｇ‘銆傝繖閲岋紝涔嬫墍浠ュ厛纭畾灏忓墠鎻愶紝涓昏鏄洜涓轰粠褰撲簨浜虹殑鍛婅瘔鍑哄彂锛屾墠鍙互鏇撮珮鏁堝湴鍙戠幇娉曞緥锛岃繘鑰岀‘瀹氬ぇ鍓嶆彁銆傝繖鏍峰仛鏃㈢鍚堜汉鐨勬�缁磋寰嬶紝涔熸槸瀵规硶瀹橀�娉曚簣浠ラ檺鍒讹紝鍗充笉鑳芥鏂紝蹇呴』浠ユ鎯呬负璧风偣銆�</p> <p> 1锛庡氨灏忓墠鎻愯�瑷�紝鍞竴瑕佸仛鐨勬槸纭畾绯讳簤浠茶鏉℃鐨勭湡瀹炴剰涔夈�瀵规锛屾硶瀹樿鍖哄埆浜嬪疄涓庤瘎浠凤紝褰撲簨浜烘彁渚涚殑骞堕潪閮芥槸浜嬪疄銆傚浠茶鏉℃鈥滀徊瑁佸湴鍦ㄩ娓�鐢ㄨ嫳鍥芥硶寰嬧�鐨勫瓨鍦紝鏄簨瀹烇紱鍙屾柟瀵瑰叾鏈夋晥涓庡惁鐨勪笉鍚岀湅娉曪紝鍒欐槸褰撲簨浜哄浜嬪疄鐨勪富瑙傝瘎浠枫�鍥哄畾浜嬪疄鍙槸浜嬪疄璁ゅ畾鐨勫垵姝ワ紝鏄庣‘鍏跺惈涔夋墠鏄叧閿殑涓�銆備徊瑁佹潯娆炬槸浠茶鍗忚鐨勭被鍨嬩箣涓�紝涔熸槸涓�鍚堝悓锛岀‘瀹氬叾鍚箟褰撶劧瑕佽繍鐢ㄥ悎鍚岃В閲婄殑鏂规硶銆傛寜鐓у悎鍚岃В閲婄殑涓�埇鍘熺悊锛�sup>2</sup> 锛�锛夊悎鍚岃В閲婄殑棣栬鐩殑鏄彂鐜板弻鏂圭殑璁㈢害鎰忓浘銆傚綋鐒讹紝杩欎釜鎰忓浘涓嶆槸褰撲簨浜虹殑涓昏蹇冩�锛岃�鏄悎鍚屾潯鏂囦笌鏂囧瓧鎵�〃杈惧嚭鏉ョ殑鎰忓浘銆傦紙2锛夊悎鍚岃В閲婇鐢ㄧ殑鏂规硶鏄枃涔夎В閲娿�涔熷氨鏄锛屽悎鍚岀敤璇簲渚濆叾涓婁笅鏂囨寜鍏堕�甯稿惈涔夊姞浠ュ杽鎰忓湴鐞嗚В銆傚綋鍚堝悓鐨勫瓧闈㈡剰鎬濅笉姝竴涓椂锛屾硶瀹樿繕鍙熀浜庡綋浜嬩汉缂旂害鐩殑锛屽弬鑰冭皥鍒よ祫鏂欙紝鍟嗕笟鍚堝悓鍒欏挨搴旇�铏戜氦鏄撲範鎯紝浣滃嚭鏂扮殑鐣屽畾锛屼粠鑰屾壘鍒板叾鏈�悎鐞嗙殑鍚箟銆傛垜鍥�999骞淬�鍚堝悓娉曘�绗�25鏉′害瑙勫畾锛屽綋浜嬩汉瀵瑰悎鍚屾潯娆剧殑鐞嗚В鏈変簤璁殑锛屽簲褰撴寜鐓у悎鍚屾墍浣跨敤鐨勮瘝鍙ャ�鍚堝悓鐨勬湁鍏虫潯娆俱�鍚堝悓鐨勭洰鐨勩�浜ゆ槗涔犳儻浠ュ強璇氬疄淇＄敤鍘熷垯锛岀‘瀹氳鏉℃鐨勭湡瀹炴剰鎬濄� </p> <p> 鎻嗚涓婅堪鍘熺悊涓嶉毦鐪嬪嚭锛岀郴浜変徊瑁佹潯娆句腑锛屽綋浜嬩汉閫夋嫨浠茶鐨勬剰鎬濇槸鏄庣櫧鏃犺鐨勶紝浠茶鍦板湪棣欐腐涔熸槸鏄庣櫧鏃犺鐨勩�瀵规锛屽綋浜嬩汉鍙屾柟涔熸病鏈夋彁鍑哄紓璁�鏈変笉鍚岀悊瑙ｇ殑涓昏鏄悗鍗婂彞锛屽嵆鑻卞浗娉曞緥鏄�鐢ㄤ簬鑸绉熻埞鍚堝悓浜夎锛岃繕鏄�鐢ㄤ簬浠茶鏉℃锛屾垨鑰呭悓鏃堕�鐢ㄤ簬浜岃�锛熻繖鏃㈡槸鍚堝悓鐨勮В閲婇棶棰橈紝涔熸秹鍙婂埌娉曞緥閫傜敤闂銆傚崟绾粠鏂囧瓧涓婄湅锛岀‘瀹炴棤娉曞緱鍒板敮涓�瓟妗堛�瀹炲姟涓紝娉曞畼濡傛妸鎻′簡姝や竴瑁佸垽鎬濊矾锛屽綋浼氬湪瀹＄悊涓紩瀵煎綋浜嬩汉鑷繁鍔犱互婢勬竻锛涘鏈�粓涓嶈兘婢勬竻锛屾硶瀹樺垯搴斿弬鐓у綋浜嬩汉鐨勪徊瑁佺洰鐨勫強瀵规绫绘潯娆剧殑鎯父澶勭悊锛屼簣浠ョ‘瀹氥�瀹為檯涓婏紝浠茶涓庡徃娉曞疄璺典腑锛岀綍鏈夊綋浜嬩汉涓撲负浠茶鏉℃閫夊畾鍑嗘嵁娉曠殑銆傚浗闄呬笂锛屽湪褰撲簨浜烘病鏈夐�娉曠殑鎯呭喌涓嬶紝铏界劧涓嶆帓闄ゆ煇绉嶆儏鍐典笅鎺ㄥ畾閫傜敤瀹炰綋浜夎浜嬮」鐨勫噯鎹硶濡備富鍚堝悓鐨勫噯鎹硶锛岄�甯搁兘鏄崟鐙‘瀹氫徊瑁佹潯娆剧殑鍑嗘嵁娉曘�<sup>3</sup> 绯讳簤鏉℃鍚庡崐鍙モ�閫傜敤鑻卞浗娉曞緥鈥濓紝鎸夎嫳鍥藉垽渚嬫硶锛堝XL Insurance v Owens Corning, [2000] 2 Lloyd鈥檚 Rep 500锛夛紝鏄寚鑸绉熻埞鍚堝悓浜夎鍜屼徊瑁佹潯娆鹃兘閫傜敤鑻卞浗娉曘�<sup>4 </sup>浜屽瑁佸畾璁ゅ畾鐨勯娓緥甯圢igel John Binnersley 鍚戞硶闄㈠嚭鍏风殑娉曞緥鎰忚涔﹀嵆璇佹槑姝ょ偣銆備絾杩戞湡鐨勮嫳鍥藉疄璺靛嵈鏈夋敼鍙橈紝鑻辨牸鍏颁笂璇夋硶闄㈠湪C <em>v </em>D([2008] 1 Lloyd鈥檚 Rep 239)妗堜腑璁や负锛屽綋浜嬩汉閫夋嫨鐨勬硶寰嬩负瀹炰綋鍚堝悓鍑嗘嵁娉曪紝浠茶鏉℃鐨勫噯鎹硶鍒欐槸浠茶鍦版硶銆�sup>5</sup> 杩欎笌鎴戝浗鍜屽彟澶栦竴浜涘浗瀹剁殑瀹炶返瓒嬪悓銆傚湪鐣鐝犳睙閽㈢鏈夐檺鍏徃涓庢繁鍦冲競娉涢偊鍥介檯璐ц繍浠ｇ悊鏈夐檺鍏徃浠茶鍗忚鏁堝姏妗堜腑锛岀鑸瑰悎鍚屼徊瑁佹潯娆句笌鏈鐩镐技锛氣�浠茶鍦扮偣锛氬寳浜紝寮曠敤涓浗娉曞緥銆傗�鏈�珮浜烘皯娉曢櫌璁ゅ畾璇ユ潯娆锯�娌℃湁绾﹀畾瀹℃煡浠茶鏉℃鏁堝姏鎵��鐢ㄧ殑娉曞緥鈥濄�<sup>6</sup> 鎵�互涓ユ牸鍦拌锛岀郴浜変徊瑁佹潯娆惧簲绉颁箣涓烘硶寰嬫潯娆撅紝鍓嶅崐鍙ユ槸浠茶鏉℃锛屽悗鍗婂彞鏄硶寰嬮�鎷╂潯娆俱�褰撶劧锛屾湰妗堜腑锛屾棤璁虹郴浜変徊瑁佹潯娆鹃�鐢ㄤ粈涔堟硶寰嬶紝褰撲簨浜轰徊瑁佹剰鎰挎槸鏄庣‘鐨勩�鍚堝悓瑙ｉ噴鐨勭洰鐨勪笉浠呭湪浜庡彂鐜板綋浜嬩汉鐨勭紨绾︽剰鍥撅紝鑰屼笖涔熶互鏈夊姪浜庡疄鐜板綋浜嬩汉鐨勫悎娉曟剰鍥句负鐩爣銆傜敱姝や篃鍙湅鍑猴紝鎵�皳鏀寔浠茶鐨勬斂绛栵紝涓嶆槸鍙告硶瀵逛徊瑁佺殑璁╂鎴栨仼鎯狅紝鏇翠笉鏄硶闄㈢殑鑷敱瑁侀噺锛岃�鏄皧閲嶅綋浜嬩汉鎰忔�鑷不銆侀伒瀹堟皯浜嬫硶寰嬫槑鏂囪瀹氱殑杩欎竴鍘熷垯鐨勫繀椤汇� </p> <p> 鍙嶈涓�瑁佸畾锛屼簨瀹炶瀹氱殑杩涜矾涓嶆竻锛岀敋鑷宠繛绯讳簤浠茶鏉℃閮芥病鏈夊畬鏁村紩杩帮紝瀹屽叏娌℃湁纭畾瑁佸垽鐨勫皬鍓嶆彁锛屾洿鐪嬩笉鍒板悎鍚岃В閲婃柟娉曠殑杩愮敤锛屾樉寰楄緝涓轰富瑙傛鏂�鍦ㄧ‘璁も�鍘熷憡绯婚娓叕鍙革紝鎵�秹鍚堝悓绯诲師銆佽鍛婁负浠庝腑鍥戒笂娴疯繍寰�紛鏈楃殑5,000鍚ㄩ挗鏉愯繍杈撹�璁㈢珛鐨勮埅娆＄鑸瑰悎鍚屸�涔嬪悗鈥斺�鍏跺疄杩欎竴璁ゅ畾涓庢渶缁堢殑瑁佸垽娌℃湁鐩存帴鍏崇郴锛屽嵆鎻村紩鏈�珮浜烘皯娉曢櫌2006骞村叧浜庝徊瑁佺殑鍙告硶瑙ｉ噴鍙娿�浠茶娉曘�鐨勮瀹氾紝骞惰瀹氬洜鍙屾柟鏈妇璇佽瘉鏄庨娓垨鑻卞浗娉曞緥銆佽鍛婃湭鎻愪緵棣欐腐鍥介檯浠茶涓績鍙彈妗堢殑璇佹嵁锛岄┏鍥炶鍛婄殑寮傝锛屾樉鐒堕毦浠ヤ护浜轰俊鏈嶃�鍐典笖锛屼竴瀹¤瀹氭澶勬湭寮�007骞存渶楂樹汉姘戞硶闄€�鍏充簬瀹＄悊娑夊姘戜簨鎴栧晢浜嬪悎鍚岀籂绾锋浠舵硶寰嬮�鐢ㄨ嫢骞查棶棰樼殑瑙勫畾銆嬶紙娉曢噴銆�007銆�4鍙凤級鍏充簬澶栧浗娉曟煡鏄庣殑瑙勫畾锛岃璇佺殑璺宠穬鎬т篃鍑忔崯浜嗗叾瑁佸畾鐨勮鏈嶅姏銆�</p> <p> 2锛庡啀鐪嬪ぇ鍓嶆彁锛屾硶瀹樿鍋氱殑鏄‘瀹氱郴浜変徊瑁佹潯娆惧簲閫傜敤鐨勬硶寰嬨�鍦ㄥ浗闄呯娉曚笂锛屾硶闄㈠彧閫傜敤娉曢櫌鍦扮殑鍐茬獊瑙勮寖銆�sup>7 </sup>绯讳簤浠茶鏉℃鍏锋湁娑夊鎬э紝杩欎竴鐐瑰綋浜嬩汉鍙婃硶瀹樺潎鏃犱笉鍚岀湅娉曪紝閭ｄ篃灏辨槸璇达紝闄ら潪鏈夊彲浠ヤ紭鍏堥�鐢ㄧ殑鍥介檯鏉＄害鍙婂唴鍥藉疄浣撴硶鈥斺�鑷冲皯鎴戝浗鍦ㄦ秹澶栦徊瑁佸崗璁硶寰嬮�鐢ㄦ柟闈㈣繕娌℃湁锛岄鍏堝緱閫傜敤鎴戝浗鐨勫啿绐佽鑼冦�涓�娉曞畼涔熸纭湴鎵惧埌锛氣�瀵规秹澶栦徊瑁佸崗璁殑鏁堝姏瀹℃煡锛岄�鐢ㄥ綋浜嬩汉绾﹀畾鐨勬硶寰嬶紱褰撲簨浜烘病鏈夌害瀹氶�鐢ㄧ殑娉曞緥浣嗙害瀹氫簡浠茶鍦扮殑锛岄�鐢ㄤ徊瑁佸湴娉曞緥锛涙病鏈夌害瀹氶�鐢ㄧ殑娉曞緥涔熸病鏈夌害瀹氫徊瑁佸湴鎴栬�浠茶鍦扮害瀹氫笉鏄庣殑锛岄�鐢ㄦ硶闄㈠湴娉曞緥銆傗�<sup>8</sup> 鍏舵锛屾硶瀹樺緱纭畾杩欎竴鏈夋潯浠剁殑閫夋嫨鎬у啿绐佽鑼冪殑鐪熷疄鍚箟銆備笌鍚堝悓瑙ｉ噴鐩镐技锛屾硶寰嬭В閲婄殑棣栬鍘熷垯涔熸槸鏂囦箟瑙ｉ噴銆傚湪鏉℃枃鐨勫瓧闈㈡剰鎬濅笉姝竴绉嶆椂锛屾墠鍙兘闇�鐩殑瑙ｉ噴銆佸巻鍙茶В閲婂強绀句細瀛﹁В閲婄瓑鏂规硶銆�sup>9</sup> 骞歌繍鐨勬槸锛屽墠杩版硶鏉″惈涔夋竻鏅帮紝骞朵笉闇�鐗瑰埆鐣屽畾銆傝繖鏍峰氨杩涘叆姝ラ涓夛紝缁撳悎涓婅堪妗堟儏锛屸�褰撲簨浜烘病鏈夌害瀹氶�鐢ㄧ殑娉曞緥浣嗙害瀹氫簡浠茶鍦扮殑锛岄�鐢ㄤ徊瑁佸湴娉曞緥鈥濈殑瑙勫畾锛岀鍚堥�鐢ㄦ潯浠讹紝鎹娉曞畼寰堝鏄撳畬鎴愭壘娉曠殑鍒濇浠诲姟锛屽嵆鍙戠幇鍙�鐢ㄧ殑鍐茬獊瑙勮寖銆�</p> <p> 浠呮湁鍐茬獊瑙勮寖锛屽皻鏃犳硶鍒ゆ柇浜夎鐨勫疄浣撻棶棰樸�璐ㄨ█涔嬶紝娉曞畼杩樺緱渚濆啿绐佽鑼冨彂鐜伴�鐢ㄤ簬浜夎瀹炰綋闂鐨勫噯鎹硶锛屾墠鑳藉畬鎴愰�甯告秹澶栨皯鍟嗕簨妗堜欢鐨勬壘娉曠幆鑺傘�棣栧厛锛屾硶瀹橀』杩愮敤娉曞緥瑙ｉ噴鐨勬柟娉曟槑鏅版墍鍙戠幇鐨勫啿绐佽鑼冪殑鍚箟銆傚湪鍐茬獊娉曠悊璁轰笂锛屾鏃朵富瑕佹秹鍙婅瘑鍒拰杩炵粨鐐圭殑鐣屽畾闂锛屽墠鑰呯郴纭畾鍐茬獊瑙勮寖鐨勯�鐢ㄨ寖鍥存槸鍚︽兜鐩栧凡鏌ユ槑鐨勬鎯咃紝鍚庤�鏄皢鑼冨洿鎵�兜鐩栦箣妗堜欢鎸囧紩鍒扮壒瀹氱殑娉曞緥浣撶郴銆傚叾娆★紝鍦ㄧ‘瀹氬啿绐佽鑼冨惈涔夌殑鍩虹涓婏紝缁撳悎妗堟儏鍗冲彲纭畾浜夎瀹炰綋闂搴旇閫傜敤鐨勫噯鎹硶鎵�睘娉曞緥浣撶郴銆傚綋鐒讹紝杩欐槸鎸囬�甯告儏褰紝涓嶉渶瑕佽�铏戝厛鍐抽棶棰樸�鍙嶈嚧銆佹硶寰嬭閬跨瓑鍥犵礌銆傛鏃讹紝濡傚噯鎹硶鏄硶闄㈠湴娉曪紝鍒欐壘娉曚换鍔＄殑瀹屾垚涓庡唴鍥芥浠剁浉浼硷紱濡傚噯鎹硶鏄鍥芥硶锛屾硶瀹樿繕闇�鍏蜂綋纭畾銆佺晫瀹氳澶栧浗娉曪紝杩欏氨杩涘叆鏈�悗涓�釜姝ラ锛氬鍥芥硶鐨勬煡鏄庛�鍦ㄦ锛屽綋浜嬩汉鎴栨硶瀹樿皝鏉ヨ瘉鏄庡鍥芥硶鐨勫唴瀹逛互鍙婃硶瀹樺浣曢槓閲婂鍥芥硶锛屾槸涓や釜蹇呴』鑰冭檻鐨勯噸瑕侀棶棰橈紱澶栧浗娉曟棤娉曟煡鏄庛�澶栧浗娉曠殑閿欒閫傜敤鍙婂叾鏁戞祹浠ュ強鍏叡绉╁簭淇濈暀锛屽垯鏄渶瑕佺壒鍒姞浠ユ敞鎰忕殑闂銆備笉瑙ｅ喅杩欎簺闂锛屽噯鎹硶鏄棤娉曢�鐢ㄧ殑銆傚氨鏈鑰岃█锛屾牴鎹墠寮曞啿绐佽鑼冿紝涓嶉毦璁ゅ畾锛岀郴浜変徊瑁佹潯娆惧簲閫傜敤浠茶鍦伴娓殑娉曞緥銆傞娓槸涓嶅悓浜庢垜鍥藉唴鍦扮殑涓�釜鐙珛娉曞煙锛屽唴鍦版硶闄㈠鐞嗘秹娓浠堕渶鍙傜収鍥介檯绉佹硶鐨勬湁鍏宠瀹氬姙鐞嗐�<sup>10 </sup></p> <p> 璇佽涓婅堪涓嶉毦鐪嬪嚭锛屼竴瀹℃硶瀹樺師鏈簲鍦ㄦ槑纭瀹氭鎯呯殑鍩虹涓婃壘鍒板彲閫傜敤鐨勫啿绐佽鑼冿紝缁ц�鍘樻竻鍐茬獊瑙勮寖鐨勫惈涔夛紝鎵惧埌绯讳簤浠茶鏉℃鐨勫噯鎹硶銆傚疄鍔′腑锛屾硶瀹樺湪姝よ繃绋嬩腑灏ゅ簲娉ㄦ剰閲婃槑澶栧浗娉曠殑鏌ユ槑闂锛涘澶栧浗娉曟棤娉曟煡鏄庯紝鍒欏簲纭畾鏇夸唬鍔炴硶锛屽閫傜敤娉曢櫌鍦版硶銆傜粨鍚堟湰妗堬紝涓�娉曞畼搴斿湪璁ゅ畾鏈浜夌偣鏄秹澶栦徊瑁佸崗璁殑鏁堝姏璁ゅ畾鐨勫熀纭�笂锛屼緷鑱屾潈纭畾閫傜敤鏈�珮浜烘皯娉曢櫌2006骞村叧浜庝徊瑁佺殑鍙告硶瑙ｉ噴涓殑鍐茬獊瑙勮寖锛堢16鏉★級鈥斺�琚憡瑕佹眰鍘婚娓徊瑁佸疄闄呬篃闅愮害鎻愬嚭浜嗗鍥斤紙娉曞煙锛夋硶鐨勯棶棰樸�鍦ㄧ‘瀹氱郴浜変徊瑁佹潯娆鹃�鐢ㄩ娓硶寰嬪悗锛屽簲鍚堟硶鏌ユ槑鐩稿叧棣欐腐娉曞緥鐨勫叿浣撳唴瀹广�鏍规嵁鏈�珮浜烘皯娉曢櫌1988骞淬�鍏充簬璐交鎵ц<涓崕浜烘皯鍏卞拰鍥芥皯娉曢�鍒�gt;鑻ュ共闂鐨勬剰瑙侊紙璇曡锛夈�绗�93鏉°�2007骞淬�鍏充簬瀹＄悊娑夊姘戜簨鎴栧晢浜嬪悎鍚岀籂绾锋浠舵硶寰嬮�鐢ㄨ嫢骞查棶棰樼殑瑙勫畾銆嬶紙娉曢噴銆�007銆�4鍙凤級绗�鏉★紝娉曢櫌搴斾緷鑱屾潈鏌ユ槑棣欐腐娉曞緥锛屼害鍙姹傚綋浜嬩汉鎻愪緵鎴栬瘉鏄庨娓硶寰嬨�<sup>11</sup> </p> <p> 鐒惰�锛屼竴瀹℃硶瀹樺彂鐜版硶寰嬬殑鎶�湳涓嶇敋鎴愮啛锛岀敋鑷崇己涔忓鐞嗘秹澶栨浠剁殑缁忛獙锛屼笉浠呮鎯呯殑纭畾涓嶅噯纭紝涓旇櫧鐒舵纭湴鎵惧埌鍓嶅紩閫夋嫨鎬у啿绐佽鑼冿紝浣嗘湭鍔犱互鐣屽畾锛岀瓑浜庢病鏈夊彂鐜版渶缁堝彲浠ョ湡姝ｉ�鐢ㄧ殑鍐茬獊瑙勮寖锛屼互鑷撮敊璇湴璁や负绯讳簤浠茶鏉℃鐨勫噯鎹硶鏄娓硶寰嬫垨鑰呰嫳鍥芥硶寰嬶紝浜︾瓑浜庢病鏈夌‘瀹氭渶鍚庣殑瑁佸垽渚濇嵁銆傞殢鍗虫硶瀹樺張绐佸厐鍦颁互褰撲簨浜烘病鏈変妇璇佽瘉鏄庨娓硶寰嬨�鑻卞浗娉曞緥鐨勭浉鍏冲唴瀹逛负鐢憋紝璁や负绯讳簤浠茶鏉℃搴旈�鐢ㄥ唴鍦颁徊瑁佹硶銆傚鍥芥硶鏃犳硶鏌ユ槑锛屽綋鐒跺彲浠ヤ唬涔嬩互娉曢櫌鍦版硶銆備絾闂鏄紝鍐呭湴鍙告硶瀹炶返骞舵病鏈夐噰绾冲鍥芥硶鈥滀簨瀹炩�璇达紝鍗冲鍥芥硶鐢卞綋浜嬩汉璇佹槑銆備竴瀹℃硶闄㈡病鏈変负褰撲簨浜烘煡鏄庡鍥斤紙娉曞煙锛夋硶璁惧畾涓捐瘉鏈熼檺锛岃鏄庡叾鏈皢澶栧浗锛堟硶鍩燂級娉曡浣滀竴鑸瘉鎹紱浜屽瑁佸畾璁ゅ畾浜哊igel John Binnersley寰嬪笀鎻愪緵鐨勬硶寰嬫剰瑙佷功锛屾病鏈夋彁鍙婃寜鏈�珮浜烘皯娉曢櫌銆婂叧浜庢皯浜嬭瘔璁艰瘉鎹殑鑻ュ共瑙勫畾銆嬶紙娉曢噴銆�001銆�3鍙凤級绗�1鏉¤瀹氱殑灞ヨ璇佹槑鎵嬬画鍙婃帴鍙椾笂璇変汉鍦ㄤ簩瀹℃彁渚涙柊璇佹嵁鐨勫師鍥狅紝涔熻鏄庢硶闄㈡病鏈夊皢澶栧浗锛堟硶鍩燂級娉曞綋浣滀簨瀹炪�鐩稿弽锛岄櫎鍚堝悓妗堜欢鐨勫綋浜嬩汉閫夋嫨澶栧浗娉曟椂鐢卞叾鑷繁鎻愪緵鎴栬瘉鏄庡锛屽叾浠栨儏褰笅锛屾硶闄㈠湪澶栧浗娉曟煡鏄庤繃绋嬩腑璐熶富瀵间箣璐ｏ細渚濊亴鏉冩煡鏄庯紝浣嗗彲瑕佹眰褰撲簨浜哄崗鍔┿�涓�瑁佸畾鏃犺娉曢櫌鏌ユ槑澶栧浗锛堟硶鍩燂級娉曠殑浠诲姟锛岃交鐜囧湴璁ゅ畾搴旈�鐢ㄦ垜鍥戒徊瑁佹硶锛屼粠鑰岃瀹氫徊瑁佹潯娆炬棤鏁堬紝鏃笉鑳戒娇琚憡淇℃湇锛屼篃涓嶈兘浣夸粬浜哄鍙告硶淇℃湇銆備竴瀹℃硶瀹樻硶寰嬮�鐢ㄦ�璺箣娣蜂贡銆佽鍒ょ悊蹇典箣闄堟棫锛屼簬姝ゅ彲瑙併� </p> <p> 闄勫甫琛ュ厖涓�偣锛岃櫧鐒朵竴瀹℃硶闄㈢О鍏跺鏈鏈夌杈栨潈锛屽弻鏂瑰綋浜嬩汉涔熺殑纭湭鎻愬嚭绠¤緰鏉冨紓璁紝浣嗕竴瀹℃硶闄㈢殑绠¤緰鏉冨嵈瀛樺湪鐤戦棶锛屽彈妗堢▼搴忎技涓嶈鑼冦�渚濇渶楂樹汉姘戞硶闄�995骞淬�浜烘皯娉曢櫌澶勭悊涓庢秹澶栦徊瑁佸強澶栧浗浠茶浜嬮」鏈夊叧闂鐨勯�鐭ャ�锛堟硶鍙慬1995]18鍙凤級绗�鏉¤瀹氾細鈥滃嚒璧疯瘔鍒颁汉姘戞硶闄㈢殑娑夊銆佹秹娓境鍜屾秹鍙扮粡娴庛�娴蜂簨娴峰晢绾犵悍妗堜欢锛屽鏋滃綋浜嬩汉鍦ㄥ悎鍚屼腑璁㈡湁浠茶鏉℃鎴栬�浜嬪悗杈炬垚浠茶鍗忚锛屼汉姘戞硶闄㈣涓鸿浠茶鏉℃鎴栬�浠茶鍗忚鏃犳晥銆佸け鏁堟垨鑰呭唴瀹逛笉鏄庣‘鏃犳硶鎵ц鐨勶紝鍦ㄥ喅瀹氬彈鐞嗕竴鏂瑰綋浜嬩汉璧疯瘔涔嬪墠锛屽繀椤绘姤璇锋湰杈栧尯鎵�睘楂樼骇浜烘皯娉曢櫌杩涜瀹℃煡锛涘鏋滈珮绾т汉姘戞硶闄㈠悓鎰忓彈鐞嗭紝搴斿皢鍏跺鏌ユ剰瑙佹姤鏈�珮浜烘皯娉曢櫌銆傚湪鏈�珮浜烘皯娉曢櫌鏈綔绛斿鍓嶏紝鍙殏涓嶄簣鍙楃悊銆傗�鏈夌悊鐢辨帹鏂紝涓�娉曢櫌杩濆弽浜嗏�鎶ュ憡鍒跺害鈥濓紝鍚﹀垯闅句互鐞嗚В浜屽娉曢櫌鐨勮鐐广�锛堝緟缁級 </p> <hr size="1" noshade> * 娉曞鍗氬＋锛屾姹夊ぇ瀛﹀浗闄呮硶鐮旂┒鎵�暀鎺堛�鍗氬＋鐢熷甯堛�<br> 鏈枃绯绘姹夊ぇ瀛﹁嚜涓荤鐮旈」鐩紙浜烘枃绀句細绉戝锛夆�鍥介檯姘戝晢浜嬩簤璁В鍐虫満鍒剁殑鍩虹鐞嗚鐮旂┒鈥濓紙09ZZKY021锛夌殑鎴愭灉涔嬩竴銆�<br> 1 鍙傝姊佽タ銆佸畫杩炴枌锛氥�娉曞鏁欒偛鏂规硶璁恒�锛屾姹夊ぇ瀛﹀嚭鐗堢ぞ2009骞寸増锛岀154~157椤点�<br> 2 鍙傝鏉ㄨ壇瀹滐細銆婂悎绾︾殑瑙ｉ噴銆嬶紝娉曞緥鍑虹増绀�007骞寸増锛岀4銆�5銆�7銆�0椤点�<br> 3 鍙傝鐜嬫槍閼細銆婁袱宀镐徊瑁佹硶涔嬬爺绌垛�鈥斾互鍑嗘嵁娉曚负涓績銆嬶紝2004骞�1鏈堬紝绗�3~55椤点�<br> 4 鍙傝[鑻盷鑹句鸡路闆峰痉鑺�椹竵路浜ㄧ壒绛夎憲锛氥�鍥介檯鍟嗕簨浠茶娉曞緥涓庡疄璺碉紙绗洓鐗堬級銆嬶紝鏋椾竴椋炪�瀹嬭繛鏂岃瘧锛屽寳浜ぇ瀛﹀嚭鐗堢ぞ2005骞寸増锛岀132~138椤点�<br> 5 See Ardavan Arzandeh, Jonathan Hill, 鈥淎scertaining the Proper law of an Arbitration Clause under English Law鈥� 5 <em>Journal of Private International Law</em> 425, 435, Dec. 2009.<br> 6 鍙傝鏈�珮浜烘皯娉曢櫌銆婂叧浜庣敵璇蜂汉鐣鐝犳睙閽㈢鏈夐檺鍏徃涓庤鐢宠浜烘繁鍦冲競娉涢偊鍥介檯璐ц繍鏈夐檺鍏徃鐢宠纭浠茶鍗忚鏁堝姏涓�鐨勮绀虹殑澶嶅嚱銆媅锛�009锛夋皯鍥涗粬瀛楃7鍙穄锛�009骞�鏈�鏃ャ�杞戒簬鏈�珮浜烘皯娉曢櫌姘戝洓搴紪锛氥�娑夊鍟嗕簨娴蜂簨瀹″垽鎸囧銆嬶紙2009骞寸1杈戯級锛屼汉姘戞硶闄㈠嚭鐗堢ぞ2009骞寸増锛岀85椤点�<br> 7 杩欓噷闅愬惈浜嗕竴涓硶寰嬮�鐢ㄩ『浣嶉棶棰橈紝鍥犳湰妗堜笉娑夊強閫傜敤寮哄埗鎬ц鍒欍�缁熶竴瀹炰綋娉曟垨缁熶竴鍐茬獊瑙勮寖锛屾晠涓嶅睍寮�杩般�<br> 8 鍙傝鏈�珮浜烘皯娉曢櫌銆婂叧浜庨�鐢ㄣ�涓崕浜烘皯鍏卞拰鍥戒徊瑁佹硶銆夎嫢骞查棶棰樼殑瑙ｉ噴銆媅娉曢噴锛�006锛�鍙凤級]绗�6鏉°�<br> 9 鍙傝鏉ㄤ粊瀵匡細銆婃硶瀛︽柟娉曡銆嬶紝涓浗鏀挎硶澶у鍑虹増绀�999骞寸増锛岀101椤典互涓嬨�<br> 10 杩欐槸鎴戝浗涓�疮鐨勫徃娉曟斂绛栥�濡�007骞存渶楂樹汉姘戞硶闄€�鍏充簬瀹＄悊娑夊姘戜簨鎴栧晢浜嬪悎鍚岀籂绾锋浠舵硶寰嬮�鐢ㄨ嫢骞查棶棰樼殑瑙勫畾銆媅娉曢噴锛�007锛�4鍙穄绗�1鏉¤瀹氾細鈥滄秹鍙婇娓壒鍒 鏀垮尯銆佹境闂ㄧ壒鍒 鏀垮尯鐨勬皯浜嬫垨鍟嗕簨鍚堝悓鐨勬硶寰嬮�鐢紝鍙傜収鏈瀹氥�鈥�br> 11 1997骞村洖褰掍箣鍚庯紝棣欐腐鐗瑰埆琛屾斂鍖虹殑娉曞緥搴旀垚涓哄唴鍦版硶瀹樼煡娉曠殑瀵硅薄锛岃�涓嶅簲鐢卞綋浜嬩汉鎻愪緵鎴栬瘉鏄庛�鍙嶄箣浜︾劧銆�br> <p><span class="STYLE1"> <img src="images/tixing.gif" width="15" height="16"> </span><span class="STYLE2"><strong>鍏嶈矗鍙婄増鏉冨０鏄�/strong></span><span class="STYLE1"><br> </span><span class="STYLE2">鏈枃浠呬唬琛ㄤ綔鑰呬釜浜鸿鐐癸紝涓嶄唬琛ㄥ寳浜徊瑁佸鍛樹細绔嬪満鎴栬鐐广�鍖椾含浠茶濮斿憳浼氫笉瀵规湰鏂囦换浣曞唴瀹硅繘琛岃В閲婏紝涓嶅浠讳綍涓汉鎴栧崟浣嶅洜渚濇嵁鏈枃鑰岄噰鍙栫殑琛屽姩鎴栧彂琛ㄧ殑鎰忚鎵挎媴浠讳綍璐ｄ换銆傛湭缁忓寳浜徊瑁佸鍛樹細浜嬪厛鎺堟潈锛屾湰鏂囦箣浠讳綍閮ㄥ垎涓嶅緱琚娇鐢ㄣ�澶嶅埗锛屾垨淇濆瓨浜庢绱㈢郴缁熶腑锛屾垨閫氳繃浠讳綍褰㈠紡鎴栦换浣曠數瀛愩�鏈烘銆佸奖闊崇瓑鎵嬫鍙戦�鎴栦紶鎾� </span></p> <p> </p></td> </tr> </table></td> </tr> </table></td> <td> </td> </tr> <tr> <td background="images/zhengwen_r4_c1.jpg" height=7 colspan="3"></td> </tr> <tr> <td> </td> <td height="35"><table width="811" border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"> <tr> <td width="23%" valign="top"> </td> <td width="77%" valign="top"><table width="100%" border="0" cellspacing="0" cellpadding="0"> <tr> <td width="2%"> </td> <td width="98%"><div align="center"><strong>10</strong></div> <div align="center"></div></td> </tr> </table></td> </tr> </table></td> <td> </td> </tr> </table> </body> </html>